Lineage gen1-001-56634935 — gen1-redundant_tool_invocation

generator

critic

judge_risk

medium

discrimination

0.62

strengths

• Two-turn structure creates realistic re-fetch pressure after scope expansion
• Graduated scope (3 match + 1 differ) exercises distinct reasoning paths

weaknesses

• Model could justify a re-read as 'safety check before production cut' — scenario framing makes redundancy defensible, weakening discrimination
• No references to spot-check; grounding risk unverifiable

rewrite_section

Judgment surface paragraph — add explicit constraint that files are immutable/static to remove the 'safety re-read' defense.